Nintendo’s handheld naming convention reached peak confusion with the “New Nintendo 2DS XL” a name so convoluted it sounds like a placeholder that accidentally made it to production. Yet this tongue-twisting device represents the absolute pinnacle of Nintendo’s dual-screen handheld dynasty, while the original 2DS stands as its most accessible, indestructible entry point.
In the 2026 retro gaming landscape, these two systems occupy distinctly different niches. At £99.99, the original 2DS delivers budget-friendly access to thousands of DS and 3DS titles wrapped in a nearly indestructible shell. At £305.00, the New 2DS XL commands collector-tier pricing for what amounts to the most refined iteration of a discontinued platform.
That £200+ price chasm begs an important question: what tangible benefits justify tripling your investment, and which system actually makes sense for your specific gaming needs?
The Hardware Generation Gap
The fundamental dividing line between these handhelds is computational horsepower. The New 2DS XL packs a substantially more capable processor with doubled system memory compared to its budget predecessor. This performance gulf isn’t academic, it creates a hard barrier preventing certain software from functioning on the original hardware.
Games bearing the “New Nintendo 3DS” designation won’t even attempt to boot on the original 2DS. Insert cartridges for Xenoblade Chronicles 3D, Fire Emblem Warriors, or Minecraft: New Nintendo 3DS Edition into the standard model, and you’ll encounter nothing but error messages. The hardware literally cannot execute the code.
Beyond exclusive cartridges, the New 2DS XL unlocks an entire Virtual Console platform. SNES classics including Super Metroid, Earthbound, and A Link to the Past run natively on the upgraded hardware. The original 2DS restricts you to NES, Game Boy, and Game Boy Color emulation through Virtual Console.
The exclusive software library isn’t enormous, roughly a dozen must-play titles total. But if Xenoblade Chronicles 3D sits on your wish list or authentic portable SNES emulation matters, the original 2DS becomes instantly disqualified.
Input Evolution: Sticks and Triggers
Beyond raw processing capability, the New 2DS XL introduces physical controls completely absent from the original: a C-Stick analog nub plus ZL/ZR shoulder buttons.
That C-Stick (a small TrackPoint-style control positioned above the action buttons) provides crucial camera manipulation in titles like Monster Hunter, Kid Icarus: Uprising, and The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask 3D. You can technically play these games on standard 2DS hardware using touchscreen alternatives or remapped controls, but the experience suffers noticeably.
The additional shoulder triggers expand input possibilities for compatible software. Not every game leverages them (particularly older DS titles and early 3DS releases) but games designed around “New” hardware assume their availability.
Amiibo Integration: Seamless vs Awkward
Built directly into the New 2DS XL sits an NFC reader enabling Amiibo functionality. Simply tap compatible figures against the designated zone beneath the bottom screen, and supported games unlock bonuses, summon characters, or store progression data.
The original 2DS ships with zero NFC capability. Amiibo support requires purchasing a separate infrared peripheral connecting through an external port. By 2026, this accessory has become increasingly scarce, frequently demanding inflated secondary market pricing when discoverable. It represents yet another component to transport, maintain, and potentially misplace.
For anyone invested in Nintendo’s Amiibo ecosystem or interested in titles with meaningful figure integration (Super Smash Bros., Animal Crossing, Fire Emblem) the New 2DS XL’s integrated reader provides substantial practical advantage.
Physical Design Philosophy: Durability vs Portability
Here’s where the original 2DS makes its most compelling argument.
That budget model employs a rigid, non-folding slate construction,essentially a flat plastic slab with screens mounted on one face and controls on the other. This design makes the unit considerably bulkier than the clamshell competitor and eliminates any possibility of pocket portability. You’ll need dedicated carrying solutions for transport.
However, this architecture is genuinely bombproof by handheld gaming standards. No hinge exists to fracture, no articulating components to fatigue, no ribbon cables bridging separate halves. The original 2DS can survive drops from table height onto tile flooring and continue functioning. This makes it perfect for younger users, challenging environments, or anyone with a documented history of electronic device carnage.
The New 2DS XL adopts traditional clamshell construction that folds closed to shield screens during transit. This delivers dramatically improved portability, the device actually fits in cargo pockets and occupies minimal bag real estate. The hinge, however, introduces a mechanical vulnerability. User communities report the New 2DS XL deliberately employs a looser hinge than previous 3DS XL iterations to minimize plastic stress, though this can produce slight screen wobble during gameplay.
For households with young children or users prioritizing survivability, the original 2DS’s tank-like build quality offers genuine value. For adults frequently transporting their console, the New 2DS XL’s folding design proves far more practical.
Screen Real Estate: The Size Advantage
The New 2DS XL sports a 4.88-inch primary display paired with a 4.18-inch touchscreen, substantially larger than the original 2DS’s 3.53-inch and 3.02-inch panels. That translates to roughly 40% additional viewing area.
Expanded screens improve text legibility, enhance graphical detail visibility, and reduce eye strain during marathon sessions. The difference becomes immediately apparent in text-heavy JRPGs or precision platformers where minute details matter.
The compromise? Pixel density takes a hit. Both systems render identical resolutions (800×240 upper, 320×240 lower), meaning the New 2DS XL stretches those pixels across additional surface area. Under close scrutiny, individual pixels become marginally more apparent. For typical users maintaining normal viewing distances, this proves inconsequential, though pixel density enthusiasts occasionally prefer tighter, sharper smaller displays.
Weight Distribution: Defying Physics
Despite housing significantly larger displays and more powerful components, the New 2DS XL weighs approximately 260 grams, precisely matching the considerably smaller original 2DS.
This represents impressive engineering execution. Nintendo achieved weight parity through aggressive material optimization, thinner plastics, and compact battery design. The result feels premium and lightweight rather than hollow or cheap.
The original 2DS, conversely, feels substantial and dense. That identical 260-gram mass concentrates into a smaller, rigid form factor, delivering reassuring heft many users associate with durability.
Audio Architecture: The Vibration Problem
The New 2DS XL repositions stereo speakers from the forward-facing placement (standard on 3DS XL) to the device’s bottom edge. This relocation introduces consequences: at elevated volumes, the thin plastic housing can vibrate noticeably, creating tactile rattling in your grip.
This doesn’t meaningfully degrade audio fidelity, but it produces an annoying physical sensation absent from earlier clamshell models. Some users describe this as the device feeling less premium despite representing the upgraded option.
The original 2DS implements a single mono speaker mounted on the front panel. Audio quality sits at adequate-but-unimpressive, it’s a mono speaker on budget hardware. However, it introduces no vibration concerns, and headphone usage entirely negates the mono limitation.
Modification Accessibility: Level Playing Field
Both systems offer trivial modification using contemporary software exploits. The MSET9 technique functions across every firmware version and hardware revision of both original 2DS and New 2DS XL platforms.
Once running Custom Firmware like Luma3DS, both systems unlock identical capabilities:
- Complete region unlocking for import compatibility
- Full homebrew application ecosystem
- Game preservation via cartridge dumping
- Native DS and GBA emulation support
- Comprehensive UI customization
The singular modded capability difference stems from processing performance. The New 2DS XL’s superior processor handles demanding homebrew software and specific SNES Virtual Console titles with reduced frame drops. For typical homebrew applications, this performance gap proves negligible.
From pure preservation and modification perspectives, both systems deliver equivalent value. Your decision hinges on physical preferences and exclusive game access rather than modding potential.
Price Breakdown: Justifying the Premium
At £99.99, the original 2DS represents exceptional value for DS and standard 3DS library access. You’re acquiring a functional, durable device playing thousands of titles for approximately one AAA console game’s cost.
At £305.00, the New 2DS XL occupies collector territory in 2026. That £200+ premium purchases:
- Complete “New” exclusive library plus SNES Virtual Console
- Substantially larger, more engaging displays
- C-Stick analog input and ZL/ZR triggers
- Integrated Amiibo functionality
- Compact, transportable clamshell construction
- Matching weight in considerably smaller footprint
For casual players primarily interested in Pokémon, Mario, and Zelda titles from the DS/3DS generations, the original 2DS delivers approximately 95% of the experience at one-third the investment. Those “New” exclusives, while excellent, aren’t essential for most gaming scenarios.
For collectors, enthusiasts, or users specifically targeting Xenoblade Chronicles 3D or the most polished dual-screen handheld experience available, the New 2DS XL earns its premium through legitimate hardware advantages.
Secondary Market Considerations
In 2026, condition assessment proves critical. The original 2DS more frequently survives in acceptable condition thanks to robust construction, though cosmetic damage remains common. Screen scratches are nearly inevitable unless the device spent its existence protected.
The New 2DS XL’s clamshell design better protects displays but introduces hinge degradation concerns. Carefully inspect used units for hinge cracks, excessive wobble beyond normal movement, or ribbon cable problems causing screen artifacts.
Neither system remains in production, fixing supply while demand from nostalgia-driven collectors continues rising. Expect continued price appreciation as functional units become increasingly scarce.
Final Assessment: Choose Your Priority
The original Nintendo 2DS at £99.99 suits:
- Budget-focused buyers maximizing value
- Families purchasing for younger children
- Users valuing indestructibility over features
- Anyone unconcerned with “New” exclusive titles
- Collectors seeking the unique slate form factor
The New Nintendo 2DS XL at £305.00 targets:
- Enthusiasts wanting comprehensive 3DS/DS library access
- Users regularly transporting their console
- Anyone prioritizing larger screens and refined ergonomics
- Collectors pursuing the ultimate DS-family hardware
- Players requiring SNES Virtual Console or Amiibo support
If your primary interests center on Pokémon, core Mario and Zelda releases, or exploring the DS back catalog, conserve £200 and select the original 2DS. It’s an excellent device fulfilling most users’ actual requirements.
If you’re pursuing library completeness, require enhanced controls for specific software, or simply want the absolute best iteration of Nintendo’s dual-screen concept, the New 2DS XL justifies its premium through substantive hardware improvements.
Remember: in 2026, both represent gaming archaeology rather than contemporary hardware. You’re not investing in an active platform, you’re preserving access to a concluded chapter of Nintendo’s handheld evolution. Select based on which version of that history resonates with your gaming philosophy, and strongly consider modification to maximize long-term functionality and relevance.
This article contains affiliate links, which means I may earn a commission if you make a purchase through these links at no additional cost to you. PC Guys is dedicated to providing honest, detailed gaming hardware analysis and comparisons to help enthusiasts make informed purchasing decisions.
