My apologies for the earlier confusion! Let’s dive into a proper assessment for Pokémon Y on the Nintendo 3DS.
Examining the listing you provided (particularly that staggering £119.42 price point), it’s evident this title has transitioned from a “standard handheld release” to a “collector’s piece” in 2026. Here’s a comprehensive breakdown of whether it justifies that investment and how it stands up today.
The Revolutionary Shift
When Pokémon Y debuted, it represented genuine revolution. It marked the first occasion the main series transitioned into complete 3D rendering, and even now, the Kalos Region (drawing inspiration from France) remains among the franchise’s most aesthetically accomplished settings. It introduced Mega Evolution, a mechanic proving so beloved that fans continue demanding its return with each new generation.
Strengths & Weaknesses Analysis
| Feature | What Works | What Doesn’t |
|---|---|---|
| Mega Evolution | Transforming your Charizard into a sleek, blue-flamed dragon (or sun-empowered powerhouse) mid-battle represents peak Pokémon excitement. | You receive a Mega Stone for a Kanto starter extremely early, which can transform the remainder of the campaign into a “victory lap.” |
| Quality of Life | Introduced Character Customization (wardrobe/hairstyles) and the P.S.S., which streamlined trading and battling functionality. | The difficulty proves exceptionally low. With the contemporary Exp. Share, you’ll probably outlevel every Gym Leader effortlessly. |
| The Starters | Froakie (and its final evolution, Greninja) is arguably the most iconic starter from the previous decade. | The secondary rivals (Tierno, Trevor, Shauna) feel somewhat underdeveloped compared to rivals from earlier generations. |
| Visuals | Lumiose City is expansive and ambitious, demonstrating what the 3DS could achieve with 3D environments. | The framerate deteriorates substantially during 3D battles, particularly when utilizing the 3DS’s stereoscopic 3D slider. |
The “Y” Factor: Yveltal
The box legendary, Yveltal, proves exceptional. As the “Destruction Pokémon,” its design proves striking and its signature move, Oblivion Wing, delivers one of the most impressive animations on the platform. If you prefer a darker, more “edgy” legendary over the majestic deer (Xerneas) in Pokémon X, this represents your version.
Why Mega Evolution Remains Significant
Pokémon Y introduced Mega Evolution to the world, and it persists as among the most cherished mechanics the series has produced. The concept proved simple yet transformative: specific Pokémon could temporarily evolve mid-battle when equipped with particular Mega Stones, acquiring new types, abilities, and statistical distributions.
The early gift of a Kanto starter (Bulbasaur, Charmander, or Squirtle) complete with its Mega Stone constitutes both blessing and curse. On one hand, Mega Charizard X or Y absolutely dominates the Kalos gym circuit. Conversely, this renders an already accessible game trivially simple. Veterans often box their Mega starter entirely simply to preserve some challenge semblance.
The mechanic has been shelved favouring Dynamax, subsequently Terastallization, yet the community consensus remains transparent: Mega Evolution represented peak design. The strategic depth of selecting which Pokémon to Mega Evolve per battle, the gorgeous redesigns, and how it rendered older Pokémon relevant again (looking at you, Mega Mawile and Mega Kangaskhan) created a competitive metagame fans still miss.
Character Customization: A Pioneering Feature
Pokémon Y marked the first occasion players could customize their trainer’s appearance beyond gender selection. Boutiques in Lumiose City and additional towns provided clothing options, hairstyles, and accessories enabling personal style expression.
This appears basic currently, but in 2013, it proved revolutionary for the series. The reality that subsequent games (Sun/Moon, Sword/Shield) retained this feature confirms it resonated. The sole constraint was that customization options were gender-locked and somewhat limited compared to what we’d observe in later generations.
The Player Search System (P.S.S.) on the bottom screen proved equally transformative. It streamlined online trading, battling, and the novel “Wonder Trade” feature (where you’d transmit a Pokémon and receive a random one from another global player). In 2026, with official servers terminated, this functionality vanishes unless you’re operating custom Pretendo servers on modded 3DS hardware.
Lumiose City: Ambition Confronting Technical Constraints
Lumiose City persists as among the most ambitious locations Game Freak has constructed. A sprawling, circular metropolis inspired by Paris, it featured dozens of shops, cafes, museums, and the iconic Prism Tower at its center. It genuinely conveyed a living, breathing city atmosphere.
The complication? The 3DS hardware struggled substantially. Camera angles proved fixed and frequently awkward. Navigation became confusing due to the radial configuration. Most notably, enabling the 3D slider during Lumiose battles caused framerate deterioration so severe it became actively unpleasant to experience.
Game Freak learned from this. Future releases either disabled 3D during specific battles or abandoned the feature completely. But Lumiose City’s ambition merits recognition even if execution proved imperfect.
The Challenge Deficit
Pokémon Y constitutes among the easiest main series releases ever published. The revamped Exp. Share (which applies experience to your complete party rather than one designated Pokémon) means you’ll naturally over-level everything. Gym Leaders possess small teams with predictable strategies. The Elite Four poses minimal threat.
For newcomers or younger players, this accessibility proves welcome. For veterans seeking challenge, it’s frustrating. There’s no difficulty toggle, and the sole method to increase challenge involves self-imposed restrictions like Nuzlocke rules or “no Exp. Share” runs.
The secondary rivals (Tierno, Trevor, and Shauna) exacerbate this. Unlike Blue, Silver, or Barry from earlier generations, these characters feel like friends who occasionally battle you rather than genuine rivals pushing improvement. They’re pleasant yet forgettable.
The Post-Game: Recognizable Gaps
The post-game content in Pokémon Y proves notably sparse. After defeating the Elite Four and Champion, you unlock:
- The Looker Detective Bureau questline (entertaining yet brief)
- Access to Kiloude City and the Battle Maison
- The Friend Safari (which relied on online connectivity, currently defunct without modifications)
- Legendary hunting (Mewtwo, Zygarde, the legendary birds)
Compared to titles like HeartGold/SoulSoul (which contained an entire second region) or Emerald (with its Battle Frontier), X and Y feel sparse once credits roll. This constituted a common criticism at launch and remains valid retrospectively.
Market Reality Assessment (2026)
Price Warning: You noted a £119.42 price point. While Pokémon Y constitutes an excellent game, that price currently represents a “New/Sealed” or “High-End Collector” premium. In the current 2026 market, you can frequently locate “pre-owned” copies at local game retailers or marketplaces for substantially less (approximately £30-£45). Unless you’re seeking a mint-condition box for display purposes, shop around!
Sealed copies command collector premiums, yet for actual gameplay, the pre-owned market provides far superior value. The cartridge remains identical regardless of packaging condition, and 3DS titles are region-locked anyway, so compatibility matters more than pristine packaging for most players.
The Soundtrack: Underappreciated Excellence
One aspect receiving insufficient credit involves the soundtrack. Kalos features some of the series’ finest music:
- Route 15’s autumn theme proves hauntingly beautiful
- The Gym Leader battle theme delivers aggression and excitement
- Lumiose City’s theme perfectly captures Parisian café culture
- The Champion battle theme (against Diantha) proves appropriately epic
These compositions hold up remarkably well and demonstrate that Game Freak’s audio team consistently delivers even when other aspects struggle.
Final Assessment
Score: 7.8/10 (The game that modernized Pokémon for better and worse, beautiful and accessible yet lacking depth for veterans.)
Pokémon Y represents the “comfort food” of the series. It’s visually impressive, accessible to play, and features some of the franchise’s finest creature designs. It lacks substantial post-game content, but the journey through Kalos proves delightful.
For newcomers in 2026, this provides an excellent series entry point if you can locate it at reasonable prices. For veterans, it’s a nostalgic trip back to when Pokémon executed the leap to 3D, complete with all the growing pains that transition entailed.
If you’re paying collector prices for sealed copies, ensure that’s genuinely your objective. For gameplay purposes, a pre-owned cartridge delivers the identical experience for a fraction of the cost. And if you’re modding your 3DS for online functionality through Pretendo, this game becomes significantly more valuable thanks to restored Wonder Trade and Battle Spot features.
Mega Evolution deserved better than being shelved. Kalos deserved a follow-up or remake (the Pokémon Z that never materialized). But what we received in Pokémon Y remains a watershed moment for the franchise, even if it stumbled in its ambition.
This article contains affiliate links, which means I may earn a commission if you make a purchase through these links at no additional cost to you. PC Guys is dedicated to providing honest, detailed gaming hardware analysis and reviews to help enthusiasts make informed purchasing decisions.
